← Arnab Goswami

misleading
confidence 85.0%
AI-assessed — pending human review

Claim

On 13 February this year, the Ministry of Road Transport told Parliament that around 9,100 deaths occurred in the past five years due to potholes, a 53% increase over the previous five years, with Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, and Maharashtra as the top three states.

“On 13 February... earlier this year, his government, the Ministry of Road Transport, replied to a question on the floor of the house saying there are 9,100 deaths that have occurred past 5 years due to potholes... This is a 53% increase from the previous 5 years. And... the top 3 states in this, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra.”
Arnab Goswami · The Debate with Arnab Goswami · factual infrastructure transport
▶ Watch source segment

Rationale

A Ministry of Road Transport written reply to Parliament on 13 February 2026 did report pothole deaths over five years (2020-2024) with a 53% increase, so the claim's core is grounded in a real parliamentary reply. However, three details are off: the total was 9,438 deaths (the anchor's 'around 9,100' understates it); the 53% figure describes the rise in annual deaths from 2020 to 2024 within the period, not an increase over the previous five-year block as claimed; and the top three states were Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, and Tamil Nadu — Maharashtra was not among them. The claim is broadly right in substance but wrong on the third state and the nature of the 53% comparison.

Evidence